My Personal Experience With E-readers
By no means am an expert on this topic but several people have asked me questions about my use of ereaders on my iTouch and on my Droid. So, for what it’s worth…
My Personal Experience With E-readers
I have used four ereaders:
- Stanza on my iTouch
- Kindle on my iTouch and Droid phone
- Barnes & Noble ereader on my iTouch
- and, most recently, the Nook reader (from Barnes & Noble) on my iTouch and Droid
All four apps are free.
I found Stanza when looking for an ereader my uncle had recommended named Platypus with which one can download books from Project Gutenberg (more on Project Gutenberg later). Platypus, at that time, was $9.95 on the Apple App Store. I always read reviews before buying an app. The most recent reviewer at that time had compared Platypus to Stanza — with Stanza being that reviewer’s preferred application. Well, with that review and the price comparison of $9.95 vs. FREE, I decided to try Stanza. I was so satisfied with Stanza, which has only continued to improve with each update, that I’ve never had reason to pay $9.95 to try Platypus.
Stanza allows users to download for free from the Project Gutenberg library of over 33,000 books. Project Gutenberg is a not-for-profit volunteer project that is digitizing books whose copyrights have expired (in the United States — they could, possibly, still be under copyright in other countries so if you are not in the US you might want to make sure you aren’t violating applicable copyright law in your country) and making them available to the public via free download. There a reader can find all of the classics. For more information on Project Gutenberg: http://www.gutenberg.org/wiki/Main_Page . The irony of reading the classics on a portable ereader tickles my funny bone. You might be surprised by what you can find there.
Stanza also has partnerships with several ebook resellers such as Smashwords, Fictionwise, etc. I have not purchased from any of those ebook resellers but have downloaded and read dozens of classics from Project Gutenberg. I worry about having a collectionof ebooks purchased from and maintained by the smaller ebook resellers and the longevity of those companies. The longevity of Amazon and Barnes & Noble seems secure to me (they’ll be around or part of future mergers for a good long time) so I don’t worry that my ebook purchases made from either of those two companies won’t always be available to me. I’ve often wished I could access my Amazon and Barnes & Noble elibraries via Stanza (and shared that wish with Lexcycle — the creators of Stanza).
For more information on Stanza: http://www.lexcycle.com/
Next I tried Kindle from Amazon. It’s an okay reader but lacking features when compared to Stanza. I have the Kindle app installed on both my iTouch and my Droid and can access the ebooks I’ve purchased from Amazon on either.
Next I tried the Barnes & Noble ereader. Again, okay reader but lacking features when compared to Stanza. One feature that both of these apps lacked, compared to Stanza, was the ability to change screen brightness without leaving the app and going to the iTouch device settings screen. Variations in ambient light do require changing screen brightness for eye comfort.
What I DO like about Barnes & Noble is the concept of lending ebooks. Lending isn’t an option for all Barnes & Noble ebooks, but at least Barnes & Noble is attempting to maintain the time honored tradition of loaning and borrowing books and providing a means for doing so electronically. I have a few lendable books in my Barnes & Noble account that I can loan to interested friends/family.
Lastly the Nook reader — available on Droid a few weeks ago and iTouch/Phone/Pad this week. Like the Barnes & Noble ereader it accesses my Barnes & Noble library. However, it has new and improved features, including the ability to change brightness without leaving the app AND, as long as your devices have Internet access, it syncs your progress in a book across the devices on which you have Nook installed and linked to your Barnes & Noble accounts, whether the device be a Barnes & Noble Nook device, an iPhone/Touch/Pad, a Droid, a Blackberry, or a computer. It has, of course, rendered the Barnes & Noble app I had before redundant and lacking by comparison.
I should mention you can also buy books as apps from the Apple App Store. I haven’t felt any reason to do so. Apple gets enough of my money on purchase of music and apps. Besides, I don’t want a separate app for each book cluttering my screen. One app that accesses a collection of books is much cleaner in my mind.
So, now I use Stanza if I want to read a classic from Project Gutenberg (which are also available at Amazon and Barnes & Noble at low prices but free is even better) and I make purchases of modern works at Barnes & Noble and read them in Nook. I still have the Kindle app installed since I have some books in my Amazon library, they might offer ebooks that Barnes & Noble doesn’t, AND I expect that Amazon will improve their Kindle app to remain competitive and keep selling ebooks.
Lastly, in my experience, the same apps (for example the new Nook app) have a better feel on the iTouch than on the Droid — pages turn better/faster, etc. Now, I don’t have the top-of-the-line Droid capable phone so my device might not be the best device on which to judge ereader apps on the Droid so take my comment on this aspect for what it’s worth.
The ebook/ereader market just keeps improving.
Filed under: Neither Here Nor There | 1 Comment »























































































